Workshop - Population Ethics: Theory and Practice

Oxford, 29-30 November 2014

Many believe that the world is currently overpopulated. This view has been common in the public sphere since at least the publication of Ehrlich's 1968 book The Population Bomb. But it raises deep and difficult philosophical issues: which population size is optimal depends not only on the empirical facts concerning the impact of population size on quality of life, but also on the right way to trade off the intrinsic value (if any) of adding new people to the population against the impact on existing people. This theoretical question - the question of population axiology - is, however, notoriously controversial. On the practical side, meanwhile: many discussions in practical ethics and public policy, from healthcare prioritisation to climate change, are crucially affected by underlying population-axiological assumptions, but the assumptions are usually unexamined, and there do not exist well-developed tools for varying them to take account of the range of theoretically plausible options. Our workshop will bring together those working in the relevant abstract theory with those 'on the ground' dealing with the various affected areas of real-world decision making, to generate cross-party dialogue and build bridges from theory to practice.

 

Introduction

Hilary Greaves, University of Oxford

SlidesAudio

 

Overpopulation or Underpopulation?

Toby Ord, University of Oxford

Slides | Audio

 

The Practical Importance of Theoretical Population Ethics

Theron Pummer, University of Oxford

Slides | Audio

 

Climate Change

Brian Hoskins, Imperial College London

Slides | Audio

 

Arguing for population reduction Case study: Climate change

Hilary Greaves, University of Oxford

Slides | Audio

 

Applications of Population Principles: A Note

David Donaldson, University of British Columbia

Slides | Audio

 

History & Principles of the GBD

Theo Vos (via skype), University of Washington

Slides | Audio

 

Sen and the Right to Have Children

Carter Dillard, Animal Legal Defense Fund

Audio

 

Population Ethics and Biophysics

Roger Martin, Population Matters